Learn all about the Dishwasher Safe Mod Podge formula! Find out what it is, how to use it, and see some projects you can make.
Don’t forget to scroll down to the bottom of the page to see some ideas for this formula, including glitter glasses.
It’s always hard to pick my favorite of the Mod Podge formulas, and it definitely depends on the day. However, I will say that Dishwasher Safe Mod Podge is definitely always a front runner, and for good reason. What other decoupage formula can you WASH?!
There isn’t one.
Dishwasher Safe is the decoupage formula that you can apply to glass, ceramic, and metal – and then you’ll be able to wash the item. And when I say “put in the dishwasher,” I mean on the top rack after it cures.
This water based formula is indoor/outdoor durable (though I typically use Outdoor Mod Podge for outdoor projects).
Does it really work? Absolutely!
I’ve tested many projects with this formula, and if you follow the instructions EXACTLY, your item can be washed in the dishwasher.
If you are wondering about instructions, here you go. These are the steps you should follow for success:
- Clean your project surface. I wash glass, ceramic, and metal with warm soapy water – rinse thoroughly, and let dry. If your piece is too large, using rubbing alcohol and a cotton ball to clean.
- Roll your bottle on the table to mix it.
- Open and use a soft bristle brush to apply the finish to the surface and the back of the design element.
- While the Mod Podge is still wet, place the design onto the surface and smooth.
- Do not apply the design element where it can be in contact with food or your lips. For example, apply to the back of a glass plate or 1/4″ down from the edge of a cup.
- Let dry for 1- 2 hours and then apply 2 – 3 more coats. Let dry 1 – 2 hours between coats.
- Cure your project for 28 days.
- Wash by hand or in the top rack of the dishwasher.
Now that you’ve gotten the skinny on how to use it, here are some common questions I get about the formula. I’ve provided the answers to the best of my ability!
Questions About Dishwasher Safe Gloss
1. Isn’t all Mod Podge dishwasher safe? Why do I need a special formula?
This is a common misconception. All Mod Podges are not dishwasher safe. For example, Outdoor formula is highly water-resistant but not waterproof. If you want to be able to wash a decoupaged item in the dishwasher, you need this formula!
2. Is Dishwasher Safe Mod Podge also microwave safe?
Negative. You shouldn’t microwave anything you make with this formula.
3. What is the finish of this formula?
It is Glossy – so shiny. You can see what a Mod Podge glossy finish looks like here.
4. What sizes does the formula come in?
It comes in 8 ounce and 16 ounce. You can find out where to buy this formula (amongst others) here.
5. What is the cure time – when can I wash my project?
You need to wait 28 days. Not 10 or 17 or 26 – 28! Please wait the full time frame for the best results.
6. Do I really have to wait 28 days for it to cure?
Yes. Cure time is different than dry time. Dry is dry to the touch. Curing is a chemical strengthening process you can’t rush. It is when the formula has reached its peak chemical performance (essentially).
7. I waited the cure time and my project messed up!
You may not have put on enough layers of Mod Podge, or they may not have been thick enough. Or if you didn’t clean your surface before beginning, regular oils from hands and other things can cause the formula not to adhere appropriately.
8. Why can’t the Dishwasher Safe Mod Podge touch my food or lips?
While it is water based and non-toxic (so it won’t hurt you), it’s not FDA approved food-safe. it would be very unusual for a glue to be approved for use with food! So please keep it away from anything edible.
9. How do I prepare my surface to apply this formula?
Clean with warm soapy water if the item is small – or use rubbing alcohol and cotton balls, especially if the item is larger.
10. Can I still use the formula on wood?
Yes you can. Having said that, you aren’t going to want to wash a piece of wood in the dishwasher. If this is the only formula you have, you can still use it like regular Mod Podge.
11. Can I use Dishwasher Safe with vinyl?
No, you don’t want to use any Mod Podge formula with permanent or temporary vinyl. Vinyl is a plastic and Mod Podge is an acrylic product, and those don’t seal plastic very well.
Permanent vinyl doesn’t need to be sealed typically – which is why it’s called permanent. I’m not a vinyl expert though! I would make sure your vinyl is dishwasher safe if that is what is you are looking for.
12. Where can I purchase it?
This formula is available on Amazon.com, Michaels, or online at Jo-ann.com.
Are you ready for some project ideas? Check out the links below!
Let me know your favorite projects or any questions you might have in the comments! I’d also love for you to check out these other Mod Podge formulas:
Brushstroke • Dimensional Magic • Extreme Glitter • Fabric • Furniture • Gloss • Glow in the Dark • Hard Coat • Matte • Outdoor • Photo Transfer Medium • Puzzle Saver • Satin • Sparkle • Stiffy • Ultra • Super Matte
Even though though dishwasher-safe Mod Podge is available, I have never elected to use it. Way back, when the only kind of Mod Podge we could buy was the glossy kind, it was the gloss that was the one thing that made me slow to embrace the stuff. I like a glossy finish for some things, but just a few.
I have several things I’ve made and the materials I’ve used claim to be dishwasher safe, but I never put them in the dishwasher. I have certain things I’ve purchased that say “dishwasher-safe” on the bottom, (like a vase for instance). I never put them in the dishwasher. I do not mind in the least making up a sink full of soapy water and handwashing a few things. When I see the normal wear and tear a dishwasher tolls on my dishes and glasses, I’m not willing to risk placing anything I’ve put time, money and creativity toward to save myself a few minutes at the sink.
Hi Judy! Thank you for your perspective! I definitely think you have to do what works for you 😀
I think this would be great to use on those free advertising mugs. The decopouge could cover the ads. There are also tons of these at thrift stores.
#1 can I use this fabric mod podge to seal the top surface of my patches, in order to keep patches from wear and tear?
#2 will the fabric mod podge adhere patches to leather??
#3 is the dimensional Mod Podge water prof.?
#4 can you apply fabric mod podge over the top of dimensional mod podge?
Thank you for your time,
Rissielerai@gmail.com
i have a question actually. I am new to this and do NOT have the hard surface or dishwasher safe yet. I was wondering if i could use regular modpodge for my first 2 coats then get the better one and finish with it on top?? much like others do with epoxy…
I’m wrapping yarn around tumblers and sealing with dishwasher safe mod podge. After 4 coats I’m still feeling the yarn texture. If I keep applying it will it ever fill in the cracks and be smooth?? I’d really like to avoid using epoxy.
Can you add mica powder or a drop or two of alcohol ink to color
the Dishwasher Mod Podge or any of the othe Mod Podge products?
Hi Louise! You definitely can. I talk about how to tint Mod Podge here: https://modpodgerocksblog.com/colored-mason-jars/
You can use the mica or alcohol ink in place of food coloring. Have fun!
I AM USING THE DISHWASHER SAFE MOD PODGE FOR FABRIC ON PLATES. I KNOW THEY ARE DISHWASHER SAFE ON TOP RACK – BUT ARE THEY MICROWAVE SAFE?
Kari, they are not microwave safe. Thank you for asking!
Hi! Im using if this is being used and it is dishwasher safe, it is also safe for handwashing? I just wanted to double check, I wasn’t sure if the wear and tear of using a dish sponge on it may effect this top coat differently than a dishwasher. Thanks! Very helpful info in here!
Hi Emily! Yes, it can withstand. A little known secret for people who scrub . . . you can reapply every now and again and just let it cure again!
Thank you so much! Any tips on how to get a nice smooth coating? I’ve found on my second coat it started to crackle a little and pick up the layer underneath, but i waited an hour and a half between coats?
Can the 28 day cure time be accelerated in an oven at a low heat?
Hi Matthew! I asked Plaid and unfortunately no – you’ll have to wait the 28 days!
Used Dishwasher safe Mod Podge over printable vinyl on a mug. I was under the impression that before the 28 days it could be used and hand washed, just not put in dishwasher. I drank hot chocolate, and hand washed and the vinyl bubbled up. Are you literally not supposed to use it for 28 days?? Did I misunderstand?
Hi Judith – it does need to cure the entire 28 days. I’m not sure why the vinyl bubbled up though even though you had hand washed it before. Is it possible for you join this group on Facebook and ask the question? It’s a huge group of crafters and someone will know the answer. Thank you!
If I use Iron on Vinyl on my mug, than I’m a able touse the Mod Podge over that?? Or do I still need to use it before putting the design down???
Hmmmm – I think iron on vinyl you would need to glue it down first. I would use adhesive vinyl personally!
I have a question… you see plastic Christmas plates decorated and they can de eaten off of and washed. I have a plastic “ football tray that I want to decorate with a team logo.. but what’ can I use todo this that is good safe and can be (hand) washed
Hi Anne! Unfortunately Mod Podge – none of the formulas – are food safe.
I placed a permanent vinyl made on a Cricut Joy. I did clean with rubbing alcohol. After 2 coats the clear glass is foggy.
Hi Jim! It should dry clear. If it doesn’t, let’s ask in the Facebook group.
@Amy, Hi. I used permanent vinyl on a glass and used dishwasher safe mod podge and I can see the clear dried brush strokes. Help! How do i fix this?
Hi Karen! You should be able scrape away the excess with a razor blade or craft knife! Ideally you do this right after it dries or even wipe it away with a wet rag before it dries. Note for the future: Mod Podge doesn’t really protect permanent vinyl any more than it works on its own.
Can I use dishwasher safe as base and sealer on glass with oil paints?
Oooh – good question. I don’t believe that Mod Podge would play well with oil based paints.
@Amy, thanks!
I’m thrilled to see this! I’m hoping to use the dishwasher-safe podgie for a project with my seniors but want to be 100% sure… this product *is* safe for ceramic cups used for hot beverages?
Yes it is! Stay 3/4″ below the lid, clean the mugs thoroughly, and observe the 28 day curing time! Enjoy!!
Quick question…step 3 in the process says to apply to the surface and the back of the design element. If I am using a napkin, that would not really be possible. Can I put it on a glass, for example, then the napkin and then more mod podge?
Hi Wendy! Yes, you’re fine. For more fragile/thin items like napkins, you’ll get enough Mod Podge on there doing it the way you’re talking about. This is just to make sure if people use scrapbook paper or Fabric that it gets sealed really well so water doesn’t get in.
Amy, I appreciate all of your articles and crafts with Mod Podge. Will the Dishwasher Safe formula work for repairing a broken china platter? I was going to use Gorilla Glue but don’t think it’s food safe. The broken piece is towards the edge where food doesn’t need to be placed. And this platter isn’t used much at all so we don’t have to be concerned about it being exposed to water regularly. Any help with this repair project is greatly appreciated! Thank you! Denise
Hi Denise! Mod Podge doesn’t hold ceramic. I do recommend Gorilla Glue or another ceramic glue for this purpose. It should still be fine if food isn’t near it!
Can you use dishwasher modge podge in a canvas bag they may be washed occasionally, in the washing machine of course?
Hi Sarah! Fabric Mod Podge is made for this purpose. I’ve never tried washing Mod Podge Dishwasher Safe in the washing machine. If you already own a bottle of it, you could glue two scrap pieces of fabric together, let them dry, and wash to see if it would work. That’s what I would do! Otherwise, I’d purchase Fabric Mod Podge.
Question(s): Does this only work with paper or fabric on a glass (or ceramic etc) surface to make it waterproof enough to be able to wash it?
I ask because I want to decorate different glassware (wine glasses, vases, etc.) with seed beads or other very small non flat materials that can at least be washed by hand without harming my artwork. Can I do this with the dishwasher safe Modge Podge? Or is there another Modge Podge product offered that will have the results I’m looking for & needing so as to not damage what I’ve created?
*(I’m really hoping I get an answer to this as it doesn’t look like the comments below have been answered as of yet & it has been many months since they posted)
Hi Kristine – I’ve answered all the questions and I can see my responses so I’m not sure why are you aren’t seeing them . . . but to answer your question, it will seal lots of things to a surface but not three dimensional objects. There isn’t a Mod Podge available that will do what you’re looking to do, and unfortunately I’m not sure what product would work for this purpose.
I was wondering if you could elaborate on the curing process. What exactly do I need to do?
Hi Laura! Sure. So the difference between drying and curing first. Dry is when it’s dried to the touch. Curing is when the little particles have reached their maximum hardness and bond – and it takes longer. So once the mug is dry to the touch, you need to leave it for 28 days more for the bonding and hardness to happen so that it can be washed. You don’t need to “do” anything except leave the item to sit. You can use it and rinse it out gently, but don’t hand wash or place in the dishwasher until it’s cured. I hope that helps.
Nice you have been outdoors..i live southern california😊
I been trying to put a picture on a champagne bottle but all the videos i see are decorating the whole bottle and i just want put the picture on the bottle when i tey dows not looks good ..do you have any ideas? How do it good?
I used the dishwasher safe on a yeti water bottle for our son, it cured for 28 days. He took it to field day and brought it home, it started peeling.. how do I fix it!?
Hi Cassandra! I wouldn’t use Dishwasher Safe with Yeti. They put coatings on their mugs that don’t work well with Mod Podge (or other acrylic products). I’d use permanent vinyl OR coat the Yeti with resin as a final finish.
Hi I’m wondering if I use the dishwasher safe mod podge over regular acrylic paint not made for glass on a wine glass or glass vase would it seal it so that it doesn’t wash off? Thanks!
Hi Jodi! Hmmm . . . I wouldn’t try that only because I believe that original acrylic paint will peel. But you know . . . I’m not quite sure. It would require a test. I’ve always used glass paint!
Thank you for all of your help! I used spray paint on a mug & a wine glass, then applied stickers, & then the dishwasher safe mod podge. I’m still in the creation process…first question- was that a bad idea? 2nd question- is there such thing as too many coats? You said somewhere that perhaps it didn’t work bc the coats weren’t thick enough. I feel like all of my coats are so thin.
Can I use midge lodge dishwasher safe gloss as a sealer over hand painted glass paint( vitral) which was painted on wine glasses and ceramic plates
Yes ma’am! You can. I’m not sure of the Vitrail curing instructions though. Do you need it? If it’s not Dishwasher Safe with the Pebeo, the MP will work. Just be sure to observe the curing instructions and always hand wash!
Oops. Pardon my typo. Modge podge not MIDGE LODGE 😂
Haha! Not a problem. Sometimes I make mistakes with the typing too lol
hi i have a really old kitchen table that i want to decoupage and i was told to use Dishwasher Safe Mod Podge. was this recommendation correct?
I would use Hard Coat Mod Podge. It’s made for furniture: https://modpodgerocksblog.com/mod-podge-hard-coat/
Dishwasher safe is made for things that go into the Dishwasher. You’ll want to use Hard Coat, and if your table is going to get wet a lot, just paint a clear waterproof sealer on top to make it tougher: https://modpodgerocksblog.com/is-mod-podge-waterproof/
Does this also add UV light (sunlight) protection as well ?
I do not see UV mentioned anywhere.
No, it does not add UV protection. Mod Podge Ultra has UV protection!
Nice information.Quick question, what Mod Podge do I use to glue fabric to flip flops? Thank you in advance for your answer.
We have a tutorial here! https://modpodgerocksblog.com/scrap-fabric-wrapped-summer-diy-sandals/
Having said that, you don’t have to use the fabric formula. You can use Gloss or Matte.
I was thinking about using mod podge for making tumblers, do you recommend this? if so what do you think is the best way to go about this?
Hi Meaghan! The Mod Podge works great if you want to do something like this: https://modpodgerocksblog.com/diy-travel-mug/ or something like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RCIipsGmOew
If you want to do one that is more durable, you can use the resin: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JKztsNsOITA
It’s really up to personal preference! The resin is longer lasting.
Is there a way to remove disheasher safe modge podge from a ceramic deviled egg plate? I painted it on 12 hours ago and I sat it in our mini oven to dry (i know but its only place to keep my tiny humans from touching) and well my hubby didn’t see it in the oven and turned it on to preheat…..
Long story short: I have brown discovered spots all over it and its an egg plate so its not easily “scraped off” Can the modge podge be removed? If so, what do I use?
Hi Courtney! I have a post about that: https://modpodgerocksblog.com/how-to-remove-mod-podge/
I would try soaking it. Although with the baking, I don’t know if that will work. I’ve never experienced the brown issue. Sorry that happened to you!
Can you use a Transparent ceramic paint over the dishwasher safe medium?
That is a good question – I’m not sure. If you are talking about for firing it, no – you can’t fire Dishwasher Safe. Which I think you need to do to that ceramic paint to make it work?
I make Velcro patches for teams. I print the pattern on mailing labels with an inkjet printer and stick them on the hook side of the velcro. Will the dishwasher safe also be machine washable?
Hi Joseph! I would use something way stronger for that, given that Velcro has some plastic in it and Mod Podge doesn’t work well with polymers. I think there would be a better product that I would ask about at the fabric store . . . Dishwasher Safe Mod Podge is more for decoupage on items that you would like to wash in the dishwasher, top rack. It’s not meant for these type of applications! Thank you.
Why does this take acrylic paint off my tile? I painted and left to dry then as I applied the modpodge it’s lifted the paint!
Was it paint made for tile? It’s not the Mod Podge – it would happen with any product. It’s because the paint isn’t adhered to the tile as it should be. That means it’s either not multisurface or glass or it wasn’t cured or dried properly!
I was recently at a craft show and a lady was selling dishes that were Mod Podge with material and she they were dishwater and microwave safe is this true?
They might be dishwasher safe (top rack) but they are not microwave safe with just Mod Podge. I address in the post! Now if she’s doing something else to them with a different craft material that I am unaware of . . . that could be. If it’s just Mod Podge, no.
Hi there,
I wanted to try alcohol ink mugs…
I tested it with 3 cots 1hr in between, for 28 days, too rack off the dishwasher and it peeled off? Why? I want to sell these!! I can’t clean it as alcohol ink will run off! What should I do!??
Hello! Since you aren’t decoupaging paper or fabric to the mug, you’re probably going to want to use something else. I would try this process: https://www.dickblick.com/project-ideas/create-custom-alcohol-ink-mugs/
Alcohol inks are somewhat tricky and are water soluble so the interaction with Mod Podge . . . is different. I recommend Mod Podge Dishwasher Safe for instances where you want to attach fabric, paper, glitter or other raised items. When you’re just dyeing or painting, there are tougher solutions.
Can this be used to revamp a stand mixer?
It really depends on what you are doing! If you are attaching paper or fabric, you’ll really have to rough up the surface to get the Mod Podge to stick. This is because those stand mixers have a coating on them and are waterproof. If you paint it, here’s the guide: https://www.thekitchn.com/how-to-paint-a-kitchenaid-stand-mixer-255810
Hi there, new to Mod Podge. I am using the dishwasher safe to make coasters. I am aware that I need to cure for 28 days, I also wanted to add a coat or 2 of the Mod Podge clear acrylic sealer for extra protection, should I wait until the curing process is complete before sealing?
Thank you
Hi Ginette! The curing is just for it to reach its maximum strength. You can go ahead and apply sealer any time!
Dishwasher safe mod podge fabric on glass – I have about 40 plates standing upright on plate racks for about 2 weeks now. Is the 28 day cure time only for washing the plates? Can I safely pack up my plates or do I need to wait the 28 days to even pack them up. These are Xmas gifts so they are not going to be given out for quite some time.
Have you ever successfully removed dishwasher-safe modpodge after it’s been curing for a few days? I did a project with it, and I’m not thrilled with the results. I’d like to remove it and start over but not sure if there’s a product I could use to remove it, and wondering if you’ve tried anything that worked?
Your ability to remove a glue totally depends on the glue but also where it is in the curing process. You’re early in the process so it should be somewhat easy(ish) to remove. Check out this post: https://modpodgerocksblog.com/how-to-remove-mod-podge/
Can we apply dishwasher safe mod podge on a clear coated lacquered Brass metal bowl ?
Hi Amaan! Hmmmm . . if it’s lacquered, it might not *take* the Dishwasher Safe Mod Podge really well. Mod Podge and other acrylic products don’t always work well with other sealers. You could test it. But my guess is no.
I am painting a stainless steel flask, sealing with Mod podge dishwaher safe. If I keep the flask in the freezer, will the sealer still work? how about the refrigerator?
Hi Laura! Hmmm . . . Mod Podge isn’t a good sealer for stainless. It has a coating on it (stainless does). You’ll have to find a paint that works with stainless, or a stainless sealer. I don’t know that any acrylic products will work. The issue is you being able to scratch it all off. The paint needs to bond with the surface, not just the Mod Podge.
Just Q why is dishwasher mode podge after drying .still sticky. I used or decoupaged jars. And the bottom of the jars sticks to surface. Looking f forward to hear from you?
Hi Anda! You can spray clear acrylic sealer over the top to dull the tackiness!
Which mod podge formula would you use on baby toys? I want to make a board book and seal the paper pictures to wood boards.
Hi Judy! You can use any of the formulas for baby toys, I used Matte on blocks here: https://modpodgerocksblog.com/decorate-wood-blocks/
But just FYI, Mod Podge isn’t meant to be put in kids’ mouths. It’s non-toxic but also not food safe. I just have to give you that disclaimer!
I use this on my clear glass cup after I had applied permanent vinyl to it and I put only 1 thin layer but it made the glass foggy and its been over 28 days now, what did I do wrong? (I did use the Mod podge application brushes.)
Hi Angie! You are seeing the Dishwasher Safe Mod Podge where it dried, so you didn’t do anything wrong. It’s a clear product, but not crystal clear on clear glass, so you will see a film. Mod Podge isn’t meant to be used with vinyl, and permanent vinyl doesn’t need to be sealed.
Hello: Can I use dishwasher-safe Mod Podge over an acrylic painted bisqued ceramic tray?
If not, are there any paints, inks, or oxides that would work with dishwasher-safe Mod Podge on a bisqued ceramic tray?
So it should be pretty porous I’m assuming? You should be fine. Having said that, I’ve never done it. But Mod Podge works fine with bisque and acrylic paint. Do a test first!
Which product would you use to make a stiff dish scrubber. Like the ones that are just a piece of stiffened beach towel.
You say the dishwasher safe ModPodge isn’t food safe, but if its being used to wash dishes…..
Dishwasher ModPodge? Hardcoat ModPodge? Something else?
Hi Christina! I wouldn’t use Mod Podge. It’s not meant for that type of application. Those are called Swedish dish cloths and they are made of “100 percent naturally biodegradable cellulose or a combination of wood pulp and renewable cotton.” You could also make them out of jute. https://www.papernstitchblog.com/natural-diy-dish-scrubber/
Can dishwasher Mod Podge be used when ironing on napkins/tissue/fabric on glass?
Can glitter Mod Podge be applied to the glass first and then follow with dishwasher safe applications after the ironing is done?
I have some sea shells I want to use in my planter in my front yard which gets direct sun light. Will this Mod Podge work to preserve the color of my shells? Thank you!
Only the outdoor is UV friendly. But since you’re not decoupaging, you can just get a UV sealer. Keep in mind that if you’re in Florida, AZ, CA, and the rays are super harsh, acrylic products might not be enough. You might need something more industrial or to move them to a different location. The suns rays are so damaging to acrylic even with UV protection.
Hi Amy,
I use the dishwasher safe mod podge on my hand painted wooden serving trays (because of hot drinks/cold drinks potentially being served.
Do you think I could apply an acrylic varnish (to protect the paint from UV) and then use the mod podge over the top? Or the other way around?
I looked up the ultra mod podge bottles but reviews said the spray nozzles got clogged. Thinking my acrylic varnish will do the job just worried about the order of application! Thanks
I have some new plain cork placemats and coasters, I don’t want to dishwasher them. I want to stamp rather than decoupage them, and seal them to prevent staining. I don’t want plates and cups to stick to the mats.
Is dishwasher proof Modge Podge what I need?
I want to put pictures on a plastic cooler. Which mod podge is best for this project?
I am looking for a food grade varnish and came across your piece about dishwasher safe mod podge – you then say it isn’t food safe. I was wondering why you would put stuff in the dishwasher if it hadn’t had food on it? I am confused 😂
I want to decoupage scallop shells to make little serving dishes. Many thanks, Hilly
Hi Hillary! You can attach fabric to the bottom of clear glass plates – glitter to mugs below the rim . . . stuff like that. So these items are decoupaged but the decoupage areas aren’t touching food or a mouth. While Mod Podge isn’t toxic, it’s just not food grade. People let food touch it (that is up to the individual) but I can’t recommend it.
I am intending to use my Mason jars for foaming soap dispensers. I thought this would give the best protection from water……., but I want them matte. Can I use this first to make them more water safe then top coat with a matte spray/modge podge just to have the finish? I would not picture anyone ever washing it in the washing machine, but just want to make sure it’s as sealed as possible in that environment. Thanks in advance (I have asked to join the Facebook group, but haven’t been approved yet)
I used mod podge dishwasher safe with food coloring to do stained glass jars I washes the jars before starting and dried them and painted them and waited for it to cure a long time and it came off when it got wet what am I doing wrong