If I had a penny for every time I've been asked a certain question about Mod Podge, I'd be a millionaire. If you're wondering what that question is, here it is:
“Which ink pad/pens/pencils/markers can I use with Mod Podge – with no smearing?”
It's not asked exactly that way every single time (that would be amazing), but it's pretty close. I got embarrassed for awhile when I did get asked because I couldn't remember the answer. “Wait,” I'd say to myself, “does that ink pad work on top of Mod Podge or below it . . . or both?” Plus I'm getting older and who can keep track of all that?! It made the most sense to do this experiment and write it all down in a post, which is what I'm doing here.
So what did I test? Two things:
- if a product smeared when Mod Podge was applied over the top of it
- if a product smeared when applied to the top of dried Mod Podge
And here's what I tested:
- Ballpoint pen
- Artist pens
- Gel pens
- Lead pencil
- Chalk pencils
- Colored pencils
- Watercolor pencils
- Crayons
- Chalk
- Oil pastels
- Charcoal sticks
- Ink pads – CraftSmart, Colorbox, Encore!, Memento Luxe, Ranger Archival Ink, StazOn, Tim Holtz Distress Ink
- Markers – Copic, Crayola, Liquitex paint, Prismacolor Premier, Sharpie regular, Sharpie oil based, Rust-o-leum stain, Tombow waterbased brush pens
Here are the results. And you need to read carefully. Not because I don't think you can read, but because I want to make sure you fully understand the results – which I will try to explain as clearly as possible! Let's start with:
UNDER MOD PODGE
For this experiment, I applied each item to a piece of white scrapbook paper – all items were applied to the exact same type of paper, which is the type you can get in the scrapbooking aisle at your local craft store. Each item was allowed to sit/dry for 20 minutes before Mod Podge was applied, even if it didn't technically need “dry time.” I also brushed over each item about 3 – 4 times with Mod Podge and a regular paint brush.
Here are the results of the smear test. Successful means that the item didn't smear when Mod Podge was applied on the top – and I would endorse using this product with Mod Podge over the top with no hesitation. Any other result is explained.
PENCILS & PENS
- Colored pencils – successful
- Chalk pencils – successful
- Gel pens – successful
- Watercolor pencils – moderately successful. On about the third or fourth brushstroke, I started to get some smearing. This makes sense because the watercolor pencils are water activated, and Mod Podge is a waterbased product (so the pencils are acting as they are supposed to).
- Montana acrylic paint pen – successful
- Faber-Castell artist pens –successful (other technical pens like Rapidograph would work as well)
BASICS & ART MEDIUMS
- Ballpoint pen – successful
- Lead pencil – successful
- Crayola crayons – successful
- Crayola chalk – moderately successful. Seems like some of the dust from the chalk got caught in the Mod Podge/brush and started smearing, even though I blew the dust away.
- Cray-Pas oil pastels – successful
- Primo charcoal sticks – unsuccessful. No surprise here. I didn't expect this to work since the idea of charcoal sticks is that they smear. But I wanted to see what happened and show the results!
INK PADS
Any bad stamping is because of a shaky hand – please excuse. :0
- CraftSmart ink pad – unsuccessful. There's a smear though it's very slight.
- Colorbox ink pad – unsuccessful. Moderate smear.
- Encore! ink pad – unsuccessful. Major smearing!
- Memento LUXE ink pad – successful
- Ranger Archival Ink – successful
- StazOn ink pad – successful
- Tim Holtz Distress Ink – successful. (the slight bleeding on the page is because this is a thinner ink and it's interacting with the scrapbook paper, not the Mod Podge)
MARKERS
- Copic marker – successful
- Crayola markers – unsuccessful. Major smearing.
- Liquitex paint markers – successful
- Prismacolor Premier markers – successful
- Sharpie regular marker – successful
- Sharpie oil based marker – successful
- Rust-o-leum stain marker – successful
- Tombow waterbased brush pens – unsuccessful. If you're going to Mod Podge with markers, I'd suggest sticking with some of those above that worked!
Okay, now that we're done with that . . . let's move on to:
OVER MOD PODGE
For this experiment, I applied Mod Podge to the scrapbook paper in approximately two layers and let it dry for 30 minutes – an hour depending on the page. Basically, you would want your Mod Podge dry to the touch for this. Once the Mod Podge was dry, I applied the item on top, THEN I let that dry for 20 minutes. The last step was to run my finger across it to see if it smeared.
Here are the results of the smear test. Successful means that the item didn't smear with my finger when applied ON TOP OF Mod Podge – and I would endorse using this product on top of Mod Podge with no hesitation. Any other result is explained.
PENCILS & PENS
- Colored pencils – unsuccessful. Very difficult to apply to paper, even with pressure.
- Chalk pencils – unsuccessful. Same as above.
- Gel pens – unsuccessful. Could barely see application to page.
- Watercolor pencils – unsuccessful. Some colors worked better than others, but none were great.
- Montana acrylic paint pen – moderately successful. While the pen did apply successfully, it was hard to fill in areas. If you were just writing letters, you'd be fine. Coloring in areas would be more difficult.
- Faber-Castell artist pens – moderately successful. While the pen did apply successfully, it was hard to fill in areas. If you were just writing letters, you'd be fine. Coloring in areas would be more difficult.
BASICS & ART MEDIUMS
- Ballpoint pen – moderately successful. I'd say you're going to need to test here, depending on your pen. Mine worked okay, but not every stroke resulted in a line.
- Lead pencil – unsuccessful. Very difficult to write.
- Crayola crayons – successful (but you need to push harder)
- Crayola chalk – unsuccessful. Smeared right off.
- Cray-Pas oil pastels – unsuccessful. Smeared.
- Primo charcoal sticks – unsuccessful. No surprise here – smeared.
INK PADS
- CraftSmart ink pad – unsuccessful. There's a smear though it's very slight.
- Colorbox ink pad – unsuccessful. Rubbed right off easily.
- Encore! ink pad – unsuccessful. Major smearing.
- Memento LUXE ink pad – unsuccessful. Moderate smearing.
- Ranger Archival Ink –unsuccessful. Slight smearing.
- StazOn ink pad – successful
- Tim Holtz Distress Ink –unsuccessful. Definitely do your distressing of paper before Mod Podging!
MARKERS
- Copic marker – moderately successful. A little more difficult to fill in areas completely without lines.
- Crayola markers – unsuccessful. Major smearing.
- Liquitex paint markers –moderately successful. A little more difficult to fill in areas completely without lines.
- Prismacolor Premier markers –moderately successful. A little more difficult to fill in areas completely without lines.
- Sharpie regular marker – successful
- Sharpie oil based marker – successful
- Rust-o-leum stain marker – unsuccessful. Too many lines and I didn't feel like I could color in the areas very well at all.
- Tombow waterbased brush pens –successful
So those are the results. I'd love to hear your experiences – and any questions – in the comments!
