Start by painting the sticks with the acrylic paint colors of your choice. You can divide colors according to ability or some other measurement. Paint the sticks front and back (you only need to paint halfway down). Let dry.
Place a bit of Mod Podge Hard Coat on a scrap of paper; enough to cover the area of the craft stick. Place the craft stick down on the paper - about half way down.
Repeat with all of your craft sticks and paper and let them dry. Make one for every student in class!
Trim around the paper. I used scissors to round near the top. Then I used a craft knife down the sides to get in close.
Once you're done, repeat the Mod Podge and paper steps with the other side of the craft stick and the same pattern of paper.
Write their names on the craft sticks using a Sharpie.
Once your ink is dry, just Mod Podge over the top. Let dry before using.